Arts thiab lom ze, Ntaub ntawv
Kutuzov: comparative yam ntxwv (raws li nyob rau hauv lub tshiab haujlwm uas yog COy Tolstoy lub "ua tsov ua rog thiab kev sib haum xeeb")
Cov dab neeg "ua tsov ua rog thiab kev sib haum xeeb" - ib qho ntawm feem nrov thiab zoo-paub tej hauj lwm ntawm lub xyoo pua puv 19, tsis yog nyob rau hauv Russia, tiam sis kuj thoob ntiaj teb. Nws tau raug lees paub tias los ntawm domestic thiab European critics tam sim ntawd tom qab cov ntawv qhia. Tag nrho cov no ua tsaug rau cov zoo kawg txuj ci Lva Nikolaevicha Tolstova, uas tsim ib tug multi-ncau khoom uas muaj tsis muaj analogues nyob rau hauv cov ntawv nyeem.
Qhov tsab xov xwm tsom rua ob cim ntawm no zoo kawg khoom. Peb ua kom pom tseeb yuav Kutuzov, comparative yam ntxwv uas nruab nrab yog ib tug lossis loj ideological tseem ceeb. Roman yuav tsis tsum kom to taub tsis to taub lub luag hauj lwm ntawm cov cim.
creativity haujlwm uas yog COy Tolstoy
Txawm li cas los, kev vam meej yog tsis sim hawm caij nyoog Tolstoy pib txawj ua si, rau lwm cov tes, tom qab ib co sij hawm nws txiav txim siab coj mus ua liaj ua teb thiab mus rau Yasnaya Polyana. Thiab ntawm no, tom qab nws sib yuav, yug lub loj tshaj thiab nto moo tshaj plaws ua hauj lwm: "Anna Karenina", "ua tsov ua rog thiab kev sib haum xeeb", "Lub Kreutzer Sonata", "Sunday". Nyob rau tib lub sij hawm Tolstoy qhib tsev kawm ntawv rau cov me nyuam ntawm tag nrho cov chav kawm ntawv, nrog rau cov tsev fuabtais, tsim ib tug tshwj xeeb cov tsiaj ntawv.
Lub neej txoj kev ntawm cov txawj sau ntawv lov tawm nyob rau hauv 1910 nyob rau railway chaw nres tsheb. Thoob plaws hauv nws lub neej, Tolstoy sim kom to taub txog lub ntiaj teb no thiab to taub lub luag hauj lwm ntawm tus txiv neej nyob rau hauv nws. Nws tswvyim ntawm tus neeg nyob rau hauv keeb kwm yog reflected nyob rau hauv lub cim ntawm tus tshiab "ua tsov ua rog thiab kev sib haum xeeb" (Kutuzov). Comparative yam ntxwv ntawm cov cim siab qhia lub cwj pwm ntawm cov txawj sau ntawv, tsis tsuas yog rau cov yog vim li cas ntawm kuj zoo kawg cov txheej xwm, tab sis kuj mus rau lub kev tsov kev rog xwb, tab sis kuj mus rau cov neeg uas nws pib.
Cov dab neeg "ua tsov ua rog thiab kev sib haum xeeb"
"Ua tsov ua rog thiab kev sib haum xeeb" - ib tug tshiab uas twb tsis muaj precedent. Qhov no tshwj xeeb cov khoom tau nyiaj li nws kev vam meej tsis tau tsuas yog rau cov teev piav los ntawm cov keeb kwm cov txheej xwm, tab sis kuj yog txoj kev Tolstoy twb tau mus qhia lawv. Secular receptions hloov nrog sib ntaus sib tua scenes, cov dluab ntawm cov vaj ntxwv thiab emperors lwm cov duab ntawm cov tub rog. Tus kws sau ntawv cim tag nrho cov yam ntawm lub neej nyob rau hauv Russia, los ntawm cov kev cai rau cov tub rog.
Tshwj xeeb tshaj yog skillfully Tolstoy tuaj rau cov duab ntawm cov cim ntawm kev sau ntawv mus rau lub xeem kom meej, thiab qhov tsawg tshaj plaws dashes ntawm cov ua cim. Txhua tus neeg - ib tug txawv cov neeg uas muaj lawv zoo thiab disadvantages. Nrog, Kutuzov, comparative yam ntxwv uas peb xav nyob rau hauv thawj qhov chaw, tshwm sim nyob rau hauv lub tshiab sib txawv kiag li personalities. Tag nrho lawv ua yog heev zajlus kom thiab kev cob cog rua nrog cov ua cim thiab lub ntiaj teb no saib.
Kutuzov: Comparative yam ntxwv
Ua ntej ntawm tag nrho cov nws yuav tsum tau muab sau tseg tias rau Tolstoy lub Kutuzov thiab Napoleon muaj ib tug meej kev ncaj ncees kev ntsuam xyuas, uas txiav txim rau lub yeej thiab lub yeej ntawm lub lwm yam. Nyob rau hauv qhov tseeb, lub sij hawm ntawm tsov rog - ib tug tsim nyog yeej ntawm kev ncaj ncees tshaj inhumanity.
Yog li ntawd, cov heroes yuav pom zoo rau txhua lwm yam, raws li tau countered tsuas zoo mus rau kev phem. Lawv cov tsos, kev hais lus, cim, tus cwj pwm zoo, dee, txoj kev xav yog lig sib txawv. Tsis zoo sib xws tsis muaj Kutuzov, comparative yam ntxwv (citations muaj li nram no) tsuas qhia no.
Lub luag hauj lwm nyob rau hauv keeb kwm: Napoleon thiab Kutuzov
Nws yog nyob rau hauv cov tswvyim no thiab kos npe rau yooj yim contradiction ntawm Kutuzov thiab Napoleon. Lavxias teb sab commander tsis yog los sim tswj, nws realizes hais tias nws tag nrho cov nyob rau hauv lub neeg lub zog thiab nws lub luag hauj lwm - tsuas yog mus npaj thiab txhawb cov tub rog. Bonaparte, on qhov tsis tooj, considers nws tus kheej ib tug tswv ntawm qhov teeb meem no. Nws xav txog nws tus kheej suab ib tug Vaj tswv, thiab ua txhua yam nyob rau hauv thiaj li yuav ua raws li nws lub siab xav mus ua tus kav lub ntiaj teb no. Nws tsis tu txog lub tswv yim ntawm nws cov neeg, Napoleon tsis tau them nyiaj mloog rau nws cov tub rog, nws tsis tu ua ntej ib tug neeg uas tsis yog koj tus kheej.
"Kutuzov: comparative yam ntxwv" - ib tug sau ntawv nyob rau hauv no lub npe yuav pib xwb nrog lub koom haum kev sib raug zoo commanders mus rau lawv cov tub rog, raws li qhia nyob rau hauv no thiab lawv tus cwj pwm ntawm lawv tus kheej cov neeg. Maj, fatherly tu Kutuzov thiab narcissistic, apathetic Napoleon - qhov no yog qhov tseem ceeb cov yam ntxwv ntawm cov nqi heev.
Tsos Kutuzov thiab Napoleon
Externally Kutuzov thiab Napoleon yog li txawv raws li hauv lawv. Kutuzov, ua rau hauv lawv ua txoj kev txawj ntse ntawm cov neeg, yog yuav luag ib txwm nyob twj ywm, unhurried, yooj yim gestures thiab ntsej muag kab zauv. Nws luag feem ntau, "ib tug txiv neej laus laus" cem taus, qhib thiab devoid ntawm tej yam zoo yog ib tug pretense. Nws slowness txuam nrog qhov kev nkag siab txog dab tsi yog tshwm sim, Kutuzov yeej ib txwm paub dab tsi yuav xaus lub sib ntaus sib tua thiab ua li cas yuav sib cav tswv yim.
Napoleon txawv kiag li, nws txoj kev yog tag nrho ntawm cov neeg siab phem, pretense thiab posturing. Nws yog me me, rog, nyob tsis tswm. Nws smiles yog tsis kaj siab, thiab feigned hais lus.
Raws li lub ntuj thiab lub teb txawv uas sib nrug Kutuzov, comparative yam ntxwv (Rooj nrog citations yog muab hauv qab no) tsuas qhia no.
Lub cim ntawm Napoleon thiab Kutuzov
Tolstoy muab Kutuzova pej xeem kev txawj ntse yog muaj tseeb Lavxias teb sab. Patriotism, sab ntsuj plig wealth, siab dawb siab zoo thiab saib xyuas - uas yog lub tseem ceeb tshaj plaws nyob rau hauv no ua cim. Nws yeej paub tias ua tsov ua rog thiab kev tuag yuav tsis tau kev txaus cai. Yog li ntawd qhov nws tus kheej, embodied nyob rau hauv nrov hwj chim, yog sim kom tiv thaiv ib tug disastrous pib. Kutuzov pom tau tias nws kev sib sau nrog cov neeg, paub ntawm nws tus kheej tsuas yog ib feem ntawm ib tug ntau dua tag nrho thiab yog raug mus rau lub chav kawm ntawm keeb kwm.
Napoleon, on qhov tsis tooj, xav txog nws tus kheej los ua ib tug exceptional txiv neej, xav ua kom twv yuav raug hu kav lub scene. Yuav ua li cas yog cov sib txawv nta ib tug embodied Kutuzov, comparative yam ntxwv (rooj qhia hauv qab no) qhia no. Bonaparte nyob tsuas yog rau nws tus kheej, nws tsis yog kev txhawj xeeb txog cov xov tooj ntawm cov neeg raug thiab lwm tus neeg lub losses, cov tseem ceeb tshaj plaws - mus kawm tau ntawv zoo. Zoo xav txog nws tus kheej lub zoo tshaj plaws arbiter, lub Fabkis huab tais tseem mob siab txog yuav ua li cas nws zoo nkaus li. Tolstoy qhia tshwj xeeb uas taunts nws, ua rau nws kom meej rau tus nyeem ntawv lub pettiness thiab tsis tseem ceeb ntawm Napoleon.
Kutuzov: comparative yam ntxwv. Rooj nrog citations
| Kutuzov | Napoleon |
| tsos | |
Ntsej muag "plump, scarred mob", "ci kaj zus kaj zus los ntawm ua tem toob luag", "stumped". | "Limited, zoo siab zoo rau lub khaum ntawm lwm leej lwm tus", "round plab", "luv luv ob txhais ceg ... ... muaj roj ncej." |
| Piv rau nws lub hwj chim | |
"Tswj pua pua txhiab tus neeg tej zaum yuav ntau dua li ib tug neeg", "txoj hmoo rau lub sib ntaus sib tua yuav tsis txiav txim qhov kev txiav txim nyob rau hauv Hmoob ... thiab elusive quab yuam, tus ntsuj plig ntawm lub pab tub rog." | "Fais fab nyob rau lub koob meej thiab hwjchim ci ntsa iab - ntawm winning" - Napoleon hais openly. "Lub hwj chim yuav poob, yog hais tias kuv tsis pib nws rau ib tug tshiab lub yeeb koob thiab yeej ...", "tau zoo yuav pab kom kuv qhov chaw." |
Qhov ratio ntawm cov neeg | |
Muab cov npe ntawm cov Kutuzov commander nyob rau hauv Hmoob "... ua ib tug general tej yam txaus siab nyob rau hauv cov tub rog ... cov neeg. Zog ntawm Guj kuj tos rau cov tshiab yeej ntawm Kutuzov thiab tshiab hwjchim ci ntsa iab. " | "Nws tsav tsheb tag nrho cov kev txiav txim zoo ntawm txoj kev ywj pheej ... ntawm nws faj tim teb chaws - tag silence reigned ... xav txhua leej txhua tus yuav ua, mus hais kom tag nrho cov» |
xaus
Kom meej meej thiab unambiguously xwm los ntawm Tolstoy, Kutuzov thiab Napoleon. Comparative yam ntxwv ntawm cov nyuag yuav qhia nyob rau hauv ib tug kab lus: lub confrontation ntawm kev zoo thiab kev phem. Thiab cov neeg uas sawv ntawm txoj kab ntawm kev puas tsuaj, tsis tsim nyog tej kev khuv leej los yog to taub. Nws yog los ntawm no txoj hauj lwm sawv cev rau lub sib ntaus sib tua ntawm cov ob tug poj txiv neej, nrog nws cov xam qhovkev idealism, Tolstoy.
Similar articles
Trending Now