Sergey Eyzenshteyn: autobiography, tus kheej lub neej, Filmography. Photo Eyzenshteyna Sergeya Mihaylovicha

Lub npe Sergeya Eyzenshteyna yog paub thoob plaws lub ntiaj teb no raws li lub npe ntawm ib qho ntawm cov founders ntawm cov kos duab ntawm xinesmas, raws li zoo raws li ib tug zoo kawg tswv ntawm Lavxias teb sab avant-garde. Nws tsis txawj tuag masterpieces yog tseem siv nyob rau hauv lub zaj duab xis lub koom haum raws li cov phau ntawv rau installation thiab directing.

legacy thawj coj

Nyob rau hauv 2025, nws yuav kos tus cim rau 100th hnub tseem ceeb ntawm lub masterpieces ntawm lub ntiaj teb xinesmas, cov zaj duab xis "Battleship" Potemkin "." Sergei Mikhailovich tsuas yog 27 xyoo thaum nws coj tawm rau daim kab xev. Ob peb paub yog dab tsi xyoo yug Sergey Eyzenshteyn, thiab nws ua neej nyob tau tsib caug xyoo (los ntawm 1898 mus 1948.). Nws yuav tsum tau muab sau tseg tias thaum nws tau lub feem ntau nyuaj thiab tragic lub sij hawm nyob rau hauv peb lub teb chaws yav dhau los.

Sergey Eyzenshteyn, uas nws Filmography suav txog nees nkaum-tsib films, nrog ib tug zoo ib nrab ntawm lawv yog hais txog Mexico, sab laug ib cim legacy, tsis tsuas nyob rau hauv daim ntawv ntawm cov films. Nws kuj phau ntawv thiab phau ntawvtes rau cov tub ntxhais kawm ntawm xinesmas. Ib tug ua tiav sau los ntawm tus thawj coj tej hauj lwm muaj kaum ib tagnrho. Los ntawm lawv koj yuav kawm tau nthuav cov lus qhia txog yuav ua li cas muaj ib lub sij hawm nyob rau hauv uas nws nyob thiab ua hauj lwm Sergey Eyzenshteyn. Autobiography supplemented los ntawm cov tsiaj ntawv, ua hauj lwm sau ntawv, tsab ntawv thiab cov khoom.

Ntiaj teb thawj coj Eisenstein

Nto moo zaj duab xis director Mikhail Romm sau nyob rau hauv nws memoirs uas nws txoj hauj lwm nws kawm cov zaj duab xis Eisenstein lub "Battleship" Potemkin "." Nws yog ib tug me nyuam kawm ntawv tus thawj coj cov kev kawm thiab muaj lub sij hawm mus ua hauj lwm nyob rau hauv lub editing studio "Mosfilm". Michael I. plaub caug lub sij hawm kho tus naas ej "Battleship" Potemkin "," kom huv si analyzed thiab kawm staging, suab, cim, dialogues thiab rhuav ncej mounting system.

Alfred Hitchcock xam tau tias yog nws tus kheej ib tug thwj tim thiab follower ntawm peb zoo tus thawj coj. Nws tsis tau nkaum qhov tseeb hais tias nyob rau hauv nws cov hauj lwm siv hom kev kawm yees los ntawm Sergei Mikhailovich. Nws naas ej "saspiens", uas yog ib tug ua txoj mas, pumped nro, tsim kev ntxhov siab vim cua - los ntawm kev siv tswv yim ntawm Eisenstein, xws li: naturalistic paub meej thiab rhiab heev rau ib tug neeg qhov chaw, txawv views, mam li nco dheev zuj zus lawm thiab ua tus kwv tseg cia thiab speeding li lub sij hawm los ntawm lub zoo mounting ntas, suab los, shading, thiab thiaj li nyob ..

Family & Cov niam txiv

Sergey Eyzenshteyn, uas nws tus kheej lub neej yog nyob rau hauv adulthood - daim card tom qab xya cov ntsaws ruaj ruaj, raws li zoo raws li ntau ntawm nws nto moo lug txhawb cov miv, thiab cov xib fwb tsis tau tsim lawv tus kheej tsev neeg. Tsis yog tus twg nws tus poj niam los yog cov me nyuam tsis obzavolsya. nws blamed rau cov niam txiv, uas tsis tau muab nws ib tug zoo kev kawm ntawv nyob rau hauv qhov teeb meem. Sergey Eyzenshteyn, uas nws duab yog qhia hauv qab no, twb yog tej tom ntej no mus rau nws niam thiab txiv nyob rau hauv ob los yog peb lub xyoos ntawm hnub nyoog.

Tom qab ib tug loj scandal uas tshwm sim nyob rau hauv 1909, lub tsev neeg lub neej ntawm cov niam txiv tau ua ib tug tsis tu ncua series ntawm scandals thiab tsausmuag showdown. Me Serge twb yuam kom mloog niam thiab papa, tsis tu ncua yuav qhib nws lub qhov muag ntawm txhua lwm yam. Niam hais tias Sergei, nws txiv - ib tug tub sab thiab ib scoundrel, thiab nws tus txiv, nyob rau hauv lem, qhia hais tias nws niam - ib tug poj niam muag. Nws thiaj li, nyob rau hauv 1912, thaum Sergei yog 11 xyoo, nws niam thiab txiv sib nrauj thiab dispersed. Los ntawm kev txiav txim siab ntawm tus Vaj Ntsuj Synod tus me nyuam tub nyob nrog nws tus txiv.

Sib yuav ntawm cov niam txiv yuav suav hais tias tsis zoo tib. Niam, Julia Ivanovna Konetskaya, tuaj los ntawm ib tug neeg uas nplua nuj. Nws txiv, ib tug neeg txom nyem neeg sawv cev ntawm lub nroog hauv chav kawm ntawv, tuaj rau St. Petersburg los ntawm Tikhvin. Muaj koom nyob rau hauv subcontracted ua hauj lwm, amassed ib tug me me peev thiab sib yuav tus ntxhais ntawm ib tug muaj nyiaj ua lag luam. Raws li tsis ntev nws qhib nws tus kheej ua lag ua luam - "Neva barzhnoe Company".

Leej Txiv ntawm lub neej yav tom ntej tus thawj coj, Mihail Osipovich Eyzenshteyn, muaj ib tug Swedish-Jewish cov hauv paus hniav. Ua tus txiv Yulii Ivanovny Konetskoy nws perevoz nws nyob rau hauv Riga, qhov uas nws tau yug los, thiab lawv tsuas tus tub, Sergei.

Cov tsos ntawm lub hauv paus ib feem ntawm Riga yog lom zem ntau vim cov dej num ntawm Mihaila Eyzenshteyna. Nyob rau hauv nws lub luag hauj lwm raws li tus thawj coj kws kes duab vajtse ntawm lub nroog, nws ua ntau tshaj li tsib caug zoo nkauj Art Nouveau tsev. Lawv tseem adorn lub capital ntawm Latvia. Mikhail Osipovich distinguished los ntawm zoo kub siab lug thiab zoo ua lag ua luam zoo. Nws muaj ib txoj hauj lwm, nce mus rau lub rank of State Councillor. Thiab nws muab nws cov me nyuam txoj cai raws roj ntsha nobility.

Sergei Mikhailovich txuj ci

Los ntawm thaum ntxov thaum yau, txiv, Mihail Osipovich Eyzenshteyn, qhia nws tus tub mus nyeem. Nws muab nws ib qho zoo heev kawm ntawv. English, German thiab Fabkis Sergey Eyzenshteyn muaj yuav luag zoo kawg nkaus. Tus tub sai kawm caij, mus ua si suab paj nruag nyob rau hauv lub piano, noj duab. Raws li ib tug zam tsis spared ntse tus me nyuam, nrog zoo txaus siab comprehending ntau yam science thiab ncav rau cov tshiab discoveries. Nyob rau hauv tas li ntawd, zoo pleev xim rau.

Heev heev comics thiab tas lauv, tej zaum heev frivolous cov ntsiab lus, ua rau lawv mus rau hauv adulthood, muab sawv mus rau lub koom haum yog tsis tshua muaj nthuav miv. Tus thawj coj qhov chaw nyob rau hauv 1957 nyob rau hauv Moscow. Nyob rau hauv lub neej yav tom ntej, humorous sketches, cartoons, sketches ntawm costumes thiab scenery rau cov kev ua si, staging rau films, dluab ntawm biblical thiab txawj kawm, raws li zoo raws li lub paintings ua thaum lub sij hawm nws mus nyob rau hauv Teb chaws Europe thiab America, toured rau tag nrho cov av ntawm cov teb chaws Europe thiab lub teb chaws Amelikas no. Tom qab tag nrho, tsuas yog ob tug films - "Alexander Nevsky" thiab "Ivan Grozny" - Sergey Eyzenshteyn ua ntau tshaj 600 drawings.

Leej Txiv Sergeya Eyzenshteyna xav pom nws tus tub kws kes duab vajtse. Vim li no, nyob rau hauv 1915 Sergey nkag mus hauv lub Petrograd lub koom haum of Civil Engineers. By lub sij hawm no nws niam nws txiv tau sib cais, thiab nws tus txiv nyob rau hauv Berlin nrog nws cov tshiab tus poj niam.

cov xib fwb

Nws sab ntsuj plig txiv Eyzenshteyn Sergey Mihaylovich muaj lub zoo ua yeeb yam thawj coj Vsevoloda Emilevicha Meyerholda. Nws adored nws thiab idolized. Nws yog ntseeg hais tias ntse heev thiab kev phem nyob rau hauv ib tug neeg tsis tau nrog, tab sis Meyerhold nws lub neej tsis kam muab qhov kev thov ntau lub sij hawm. Sergey Mihaylovich Eyzenshteyn, biography - ib lub npe ntawm peb cov kev ntsuam xyuas, sau txog nws cov xib fwb nyob rau hauv theatrical directing no: Meyerhold muaj ib tug tshwj xeeb muaj peev xwm mus kawm tau, tsis muab me nyuam kawm ntawv tsis tau paub. Eisenstein hais tias tag nrho tus thawj coj secrets Meyerhold, nws tau pom thiab comprehended sai li sai tau raws li nws tuaj mus rau ib tug rehearsal ntawm cov kev ua si.

Nw nyuam qhuav pom cov cim ntawm tej txuj ci nyob rau hauv ib yam ntawm cov thwjtim, Meyerhold nyob rau hauv ib tug pretext los yog lwm tam sim ntawd tau tshem ntawm ib tug tej zaum cov yeeb ncuab. Nws ua Meyerhold feem ntau los ntawm cov poj niam. Yog li ntawd nws mus thiab Eisenstein.

Yog hais tias Meyerhold tsis xav kom muab lawv cov kev paub nrog cov menyuam kawm ntawv, tus thawj coj Sergey Eyzenshteyn, on qhov tsis tooj, tag nrho cov nws lub neej thiab tej txuj ci muab tso rau hauv cov creation ntawm lub universal kev cai ntawm xinesmas, uas nws frankly piav nyob rau hauv nws sau rau lub kos duab ntawm xinesmas. Phau Ntawv ntawm filmmakers nyob ib ncig ntawm lub ntiaj teb no los ua nws "Art of mise en scene", "Mizankadr", "Installation", "txoj kev" thiab "tsis muaj ab tsi tiag."

Tsev zaj duab xis kev tshawb xav

Tsis muaj ua ib tug kws kes duab vajtse, raws li zoo li nws tus txiv, Eyzenshteyn Sergey Mihaylovich, txawm li cas los, nws tshuav tom qab ib qho kev nthuav schematic kos duab ntawm ib lub tsev, uas yog txhais raws li "lub tsev lub hom phiaj ntawm xinesmas." Qhov kev npaj no yuav suav hais tias universal. Nyob rau nws tsis yog tsuas yog ib qho yooj yim mus tua movies, nws yog tseem zoo tagnrho rau cov kev loj hlob ntawm cov kev npaj rau txoj kev loj hlob ntawm xinesmas hauv general.

Lub hauv paus uas tag nrho cov qauv - cov qauv ntawm cov dialectics, uas yog, kev sib tham, kev koom tes, teeb meem thiab hauj lwm ua ke koom tes. Nyob rau hauv txoj kev hoisted tom ntej phaj - kev paub qhia lo txiv neej. Nyob rau hauv lub ntsiab txhais no, yog hais txog rau hauv txoj kev nyob rau hauv uas cov neeg qhia lawv tus cwj pwm txawv nyob rau hauv cov haiv neeg.

Saum toj no, nyob rau lub phaj ntawm "tib neeg qhia", yog plaub kab - lub pathos mizankadr, mise en scene thiab cov comic. Cov kab, precisely ntau, cov yam tseem ceeb collectively, los ntawm installation, tsim tus yam duab uas muaj feem xyuam rau cov kev txiav txim zoo ntawm tib neeg kev xav. Tag nrho cov no ua ke yog lub tswv yim ntawm kos duab, nyob rau hauv cov ntaub ntawv no, tus yeeb yam. Ntxiv ua hauj lwm nyob rau hauv cov zaj duab xis yuav nyob rau hauv kev tshawb nrhiav txog Sociology thiab technology. Qhov no yog tsim nyog kiag li, raws li cov kev sib tw txojkev zaj duab xis, lossi expanding, kev txhim kho technology, ua kev pab them nqi ntawm cov neeg tuaj saib, tus zoo qauv yog nce. Crowned tsim chij nrog lo lus "zaj duab xis txoj kev".

Tej teeb meem yog cov tsav tsheb quab yuam ntawm cov kos duab

Lo lus "tej teeb meem" - lub hauv paus uas rests cov kos duab - nyob rau hauv lub tsev tswvyim ntawm zaj duab xis kev tshawb xav yog uas ploj lawm. Txawm li cas los, Sergey Eyzenshteyn twb ntxias hais tias qhov teeb meem yog cov tsav tsheb quab yuam ntawm tag nrho cov dab uas yog ob qho tib si muaj tswv yim thiab puas orientation. Nws txoj kev ntseeg yog raws li nyob rau hauv nws tus kheej thaum yau yaam puab paub, thaum nws nesmyshlony kas muab tau ib tog mus rau lub grand scenes thiab scandals uas tshwm sim nruab nrab ntawm cov niam txiv. Nyob ntawm seb lub unfolding nws yog staging, nyob rau hauv lub qhaj ntawv ntawm lwm cov cim, tau muab kev koom tes papa niam yuav ua li cas tim khawv tias tus phem tus lwm yam, yuav ua li cas lub arbitrator txheeb seb leej twg yog txoj cai thiab uas yog tsis ncaj ncees lawm, yuav ua li cas lub culprit ntawm lawv tu siab heev lub neej, thiab txawm raws li ib tug performer Tswv tej hauj lwm nyob rau hauv lub sij hawm ntawm silence ua txhaum rau tus txij nkawm. Nws yog ib tug pob, ya los ntawm ib tug ntawm lawv mus rau lwm lub. Xws li ib tug lub neej yog nyob rau hauv qhov teeb meem yuav tsis muab tso rau Sergei Mikhailovich outlook. Cov teeb meem muaj ua tej yam ntuj tso, tej zaum koj yuav hais tias, ib tug yug me nyuam rau hauv av rau nws.

Cais koj yav tag los, Sergey Eyzenshteyn sau hais tias nws cov me nyuam muaj lub siab xav yog tsis muaj ib tug ua xam qhovkev zoo tib yam cov me nyuam. Nws tsis tau tawg cov khoom ua si, yuav tsis ua kom tawm lub moos nyob rau hauv thiaj li yuav saib dab tsi hauv lawv, tsis yog mob lub miv thiab dev yog tsis dag thiab tsis capricious. Nyob rau hauv luv luv, nws yog lub zoo meej tus me nyuam. Sergey Eyzenshteyn, lub autobiography ntawm tus thawj coj hais tias ib tug daim ntawv pov thawj tau embodied tag nrho unrealized thaum yau pranks nyob rau hauv nws films. Hais tias tsis muaj ntawm lub sij hawm los tsim lawm thiab tshawb lub neej raws li nws tshwm sim rau tag nrho lub cev rau cov me nyuam, manifested nyob rau hauv nws nyob rau hauv xyoo tom ntej. Li no cov ntshav scenes ntawm executions, murders, etc., Etc .. Tag nrho cov txhoj puab heev txoj kev cawv rau cov neeg tuaj saib, nyob rau hauv lawv psyche, Eisenstein hu ua attractions.

Mystical coincidence los yog neeg tuag taus kev txiav txim siab?

Sergey Eyzenshteyn, uas nws biography ntawd hais tias nws yog kiag li muaj kuab neeg, muaj mystical cov txheej xwm qhov tseeb, uas nws txuas tseem ceeb heev.

Thaum kawm nyob rau hauv lub thib ob xyoo ntawm lub koom haum ntawm Civil Engineers, nws twb twv mus rau hauv lub vortex ntawm lub revolutionary zog. Nyob rau hauv Lub ob hlis ntuj 1918, Eisenstein enlisted nyob rau hauv lub Red Army thiab mus rau pem hauv ntej. Rau ob xyoo nws twb koom nyob rau hauv cov tub rog kev tsim kho, nws tau koom tes nyob rau hauv cov teg num raws li ib tug actor thiab cov thawj coj thiab pleev xim rau kev dag slogans qhia tsheb.

Nyob rau hauv 1920 nws tso ib tug tsoom fwv txoj cai uas cov menyuam kawm ntawv rov qab mus rau tsev kawm qib siab thiab mus txuas hnub nyoog rau kev kawm ntawv. Sergey ntawm lub sij hawm no ib tug saj rau lub theatrical lub neej, thiab yog tsis xav kom rov ua siv thiab architecture, raws li uas cog noob los ntawm cov niam txiv. Nws muaj mus ntxiv nws kev tshawb fawb ntawm cov Academy ntawm lub General neeg ua hauj lwm, nrog rau cov aim nyob rau hauv lub neej yav tom ntej los ua ib tug neeg txhais lus ntawm Japanese. Qhov kev yog li ntawd thaum uas Eisenstein xav. By lub sij hawm no lub capital twb tsiv los ntawm Petrograd rau Moscow, uas sai tsim lub neej - thiab ua yeeb yam nyob rau hauv particular. Nyob rau hauv lub fateful hmo ntuj thaum nws thaum kawg txiav txim siab mus ua txhaum nrog tus architecture, ib txhij nrog pib ntawm nws lub neej tshiab cia li plawv nres nres nws txiv lub neej - Mihaila Osipovicha Eyzenshteyna.

Los ntawm lub sij hawm ntawd nws tau pib ib tug muaj kev vam meej thiab sai ua hauj lwm ntawm lub ntiaj teb no-nrov zaj duab xis director Sergeya Eyzenshteyna.

Ua tsaug rau koj Peter Greenaway

Nyob rau hauv 2015, lub ntxaij vab tshaus tso zaj duab xis los ntawm Peter Greenaway "Eisenstein nyob rau hauv guanajuato". Qhov no daim duab tau tshwm sim los ambivalence Lavxias teb sab distributors, txawm li cas los Greenaway lub xeev uas tseem tsis tau muab tshem tawm ib zaug xwb zaj duab xis txog ib tug zoo kawg nkaus tus thawj coj - ib tug loj omission. Cov neeg yuav tsum tau paub dab tsi yog tus neeg zoo zoo Sergey Eyzenshteyn. Biography, tus thawj coj tus kheej lub neej thiab nws ua hauj lwm nyob rau hauv cov zaj duab xis yuav tsum tau txoj kev kawm thiab kev tshawb fawb. Nws tsis yog yuav los discredit tus ntse heev. On qhov tsis tooj, nws xav mus qhia yuav ua li cas lub ntiaj teb twb hloov ib tug txawj ntse tus neeg tom qab koj mus txawv tebchaws nyob ib ncig ntawm lub teb chaws, yog tsis constrained los ntawm lub totalitarian regime. Tom qab tag nrho, rau tus twg los tsis yog ib tug pub leejtwg paub hais tias tom qab peb xyoos uas kawm hauv lub neej thiab kev lis kev cai ntawm cov neeg nyob rau hauv Teb chaws Europe, Teb chaws USA thiab Latin America Sergey radically hloov nws saib ntawm lub hom phiaj thiab paub tab ntawm lub Soviet xinesmas. Qhov kev npaj Greenaway - lub thib ob zaj duab xis txog peb koj compatriot, "Sib tuav tes sib Eisenstein." Thaum lub sij hawm no, Greenway xav qhia lub neej ntawm tus poj thawj coj mus ncig teb chaws sab nraum lub Soviet Union.

outlook restructuring

Eisenstein thaum pib ntawm nws loj ncig saib qhov chaw nyob rau hauv cov teb chaws Europe yuav desyatitomnik Frazer "Lub Golden Bough". Nws yog vim hais tias ntawm phau ntawv no, nws tau sau cov lus qhia txog lub ntiaj teb no kev ntseeg txij ancient sij hawm rau tam sim no. Lub tswv yim ntawm cov deity li cereal, tuag thiab sawv rov qab, los nyob rau hauv nws lub tswv yim ntawm cycling rau tag nrho cov ntaub ntawv uas lub ntiaj teb no.

Kaum hnub nyob rau hauv Mexico tau qhib nws ib tug tshiab foundations on kev sib raug zoo nyob rau hauv dav dav thiab xinesmas hauv particular. Nws pom hais tias ib tus me cheeb tsam yuav peacefully coexist zoo tag nrho cov keeb kwm kev sib raug zoo kev txiav txim - qhov txheej thaum ub, feudal, capitalist thiab txawm socialist.

Kuv xav kom nco ntsoov tias nyob rau hauv Mexico kom deb li deb, ntau tshaj li 70 xyoo, Eisenstein yog suav hais tias yog tus naj npawb ib tus thawj coj. Qhov no yog vim li, vim hais tias nws yog muaj nasnimal plots 80 000 meters ntawm zaj duab xis. Nws yog nrov nrog neeg hauv zos thiab lawv txoj kev ntawm lub neej, lub teb chaws li kev cai, txoj kev zoo nkauj ntawm cov toj roob hauv pes, tej yam ntuj tso qeeg thiab ib tug ntau ntawm nthuav cov ntsiab lus thiab cov ntsiab lus ntawm lub neej ntawm Latinos.

Vim hais tias ntawm cov complexities ntawm copyright peb tsis muaj lub sij hawm los saib tag nrho cov khoom no, uas yog ib tug hlub. Nyob rau hauv Teb Chaws Asmeskas, raws li nyob rau hauv Eisenstein lub tuam txhab "Paramount" ntsia ib ob peb films uas tau txais lossis loj txoj kev vam meej. Paub meej txog lub tu siab dabneeg nrog films yuav tsum tau nyeem nyob rau hauv lub magazine "Soviet Screen" rau 1974, tus sau - R. Yurenev.

Rov qab tsev, Sergei Mikhailovich, ua ke nrog txawj sau ntawv (raws li nyob rau hauv tsis ntev los no yav dhau los Chekist) Aleksandrom Rzheshevskim txheej mus ua hauj lwm rau lwm zaj duab xis. Thaum lub sij hawm no ntawm collectivization - "Bezhin lub tiaj nyom." Muab raws li ib lub hauv paus rau zaj dab neeg ntawm Pavlik Morozov, uas, raws li yees los ntawm Eisenstein, raug tua los ntawm nws tus kheej txiv txhais tes. Nyob rau hauv thawj variant teb mos lub tsev teev ntuj npaj nyob rau hauv nws qws. Nyob rau hauv lub thib ob - tus peasants yog sim kom txuag tau lub tsev teev ntuj ntawm qhov hluav taws kub. Tus zaj duab xis tau raug txwv rau ideological yog vim li cas, tab sis cov zaj duab xis yog ntxuav tam sim ntawd. Tsuas yog ib tug ob peb cov duab nrog footage ntawm cov zaj duab xis. Lawv muaj kev cuam tshuam lub hwj chim ntawm tus puas siab puas ntsws tej yam rau tus tuav.

Txoj hmoo ntawm tus thawj coj dai nyob rau hauv qhov nqi koj tshuav. Nws narrowly dim raug ntes, twb tshem tawm los ntawm kev qhia ntawm VGIK, tiamsis sov ua licas kev txaus cai thiab muaj lub sij hawm mus ua hauj lwm nyob rau hauv, tam sim no tshaj ib tug patriotic zaj duab xis "Alexander Nevsky".

"Nws nyob, xav tias, thiab yog xav", - xws li ib epitaph xav pom cov tub ntxhais Sergei Mikhailovich rau nws tombstone.

Qhov kawg ntawm lub neej tom qab koj lub plawv nres, uas tshwm sim nyob rau hauv 1946, Eisenstein, cais lawv tus kheej destiny, sau ntawv, nws nkawd, twb yeej ib txwm nrhiav tsuas yog ib yam - ib txoj kev rau kev koom ua ke thiab reconciliation ntawm lub tsis sib haum ob tog. Cov opposites uas tsav tag nrho dab nyob rau hauv lub ntiaj teb no. Ib qho chaw twg rau Mexico tsom rau nws hais tias lub union yog tsis tau, txawm li cas los, - Sergey kom meej meej pom nws - lawv yog cov heev tiag tiag rau qhia thaj yeeb coexistence.