"Leej twg yog tsis muaj peb yog tawm tsam peb!" - Leej twg hais tias? Lub hauv paus pib ntawm cov kev qhia

Ib qho ntawm feem nto moo catch kab lus, uas tau zam ua ib tug quote thiab ua cia li ib tug cov lus hais tias, nyob rau hauv qhov tseeb, muaj ib tug ancient keeb kwm. Thaum rallies thiab nyob rau hauv tag nrho cov xaiv ntawm nws cov sib cav tswv yim yeej yuav hnov mob siab txaus siab: "Leej twg yog tsis muaj peb yog tawm tsam peb!", Thiab peb thiaj li siv rau lub rooj sib cov kab lus uas suav nws cia li raws li lub pej xeem kos duab. Txawm li cas los, nws muaj tsis muaj dab tsi ua nrog rau qhov paj lug thiab sayings. Lub keeb kwm ntawm qhov no qhia ntau reverence thiab ib tug txiav txim zoo dawb huv.

Biblical keeb kwm cov nqe lus

Cov neeg uas muaj ib tug inquisitive siab, tej zaum yuav xav nyob rau hauv uas hais tias kab lus no thiab yog vim li cas nws yog li ntawd lug dispersed nyob rau hauv lub ntiaj teb no. Semantic analogues ntawm no qhia yog nyob rau hauv ntau yam lus, ces koj yuav tham txog lub ntiaj teb no tej chaw. Chiv, qhov no daim ntawv qhia tsis nyuaj txawv, thiab txawm hais tias peb tau hnov ob versions - thiab yooj yim thiab txhais - ntau siv li no: "Leej twg yog tsis muaj peb yog tawm tsam peb." Tus sau muaj nyob rau hauv lub siab xwb kuv tus kheej, tsis muaj txuas rau tus nqi ntawm dab tsi tau hais tias nyob rau ib lub zej lub zos.

Nyeem tus thawj version yuav ua tau nyob rau hauv lub Moo Zoo ntawm Mathais tshooj 12, nqe 30. Yexus hais tias: "Leej twg yog tsis nrog kuv yog kuv ib yam; thiab cov uas tsis sib sau ua ke nrog kuv scatters. " Qhov no puas txhais tau hais tias nws muaj nyob rau hauv lub siab, hais tias txhua tus neeg, tsis instantly ntseeg, yog nws cov yeeb ncuab?

Kev piav qhia ntawm lub catch kab lus ntawm tus neeg sau

Ntawm cov hoob kawm, nws yog tsis yooj yim sua tham Yexus thiab hais dab tsi nws hais. Feem ntau cov kab lus "uas yog tsis nrog peb yog tawm tsam peb" yog siv los txhais hais tias "mus zaum rau ntawm lub sidelines yuav tsis ua hauj lwm, neutrality tsis muaj nyob, koj puas xav hais tias lub nruab nrab, tab sis koj nyob nraum peb cov yeeb ncuab." Txawm li cas los, Yog hais tias koj ua tib zoo kawm phau Vajlugkub zaj dabneeg, uas cov kab lus hais txog Huab Tais Ntuj hais los ntawm Yexus, ib tug yuav nrhiav kuj yog tej lus, nyob rau cov thwj tim, "Tsis txhob txwv tsis pub nws, uas yog tsis tiv thaiv koj yog rau koj." Yuav ua li cas yuav ib tug txhais lus no duality, vim hais tias nws zoo nkaus li yog hais tias tus neeg sau ntawm cov kev qhia yog kom meej meej ua tsis tau nws tus kheej?

Yexus tej zaum yuav tau muaj nyob rau hauv lub siab nruj specifics thiab yeej ntseeg tias Vajtswv thiab hais rau nws cov thwjtim - yog ob yam sib txawv, thiab rau Vajtswv ua ntau txoj kev. Li ntawd, cov thawj lub ntsiab lus ntawm cov kev qhia yog tsis raws li radical raws li tom qab ntau niaj hnub txhais lus.

Siv phau Vajlugkub nyob rau hauv lub dag rhetoric

Yog vim li cas kab lus no muaj xws li ib lub hwj, nws yog tsis muaj zem ntau radical taw vim lawv txaus siab hais cov lus "uas yog tsis nrog peb yog tawm tsam peb"? Phau Vajlugkub yog teem rau lub authoritative qhov chaw ntawm qhov tseeb, vim hais tias dabneeg lub European txoj kev xav. Unquestioned txoj cai, uas, nyob rau hauv nws kev hais lus, Nws puv, muab tus luj ntawm cov nqe lus.

Tom qab lub triumphal peb hlis ntuj ntawm cov ntseeg Vajtswv nyob teb chaws Europe siv phau Vajlugkub raws li ib tug qhov chaw ntawm ua neeg ncajncees rau yuav luag txhua yam. Txoj kev ntseeg yog ua tau ib tug haib tshaj riam phom, thiab nws yog heev yooj yim mus nrhiav cov neeg uas kam tsa muag mus hais lus cam nrog cov lus ntawm phau ntawv, tshwm sim los ntawm Vajtswv nws tus kheej. Txawm li cas los, qhov no tsis txhais hais tias nws tus kheej yuav tsum tau ib tug believer.

Vladimir Lenin thiab Max Stirner?

Feem ntau cov feem ntau nws yog ib qho kev qhia ntaus nqi mus rau Vladimir Ulyanov, zoo dua lub npe hu ua Lenin - ideological thawj coj ntawm lub kaum hli ntuj kiv puag ncig ntawm lub Lavxias teb sab faj tim teb chaws nyob rau hauv thaum pib ntawm lub xeem caug xyoo. Lub ADDRESSEE yog ib tug neeg sab nrauv ntawm lub Social Democrats uas ho tsis txhawb lub tswv yim ntawm cov revolutionary qaug dab peg ntawm lub hwj chim. Kuj ceeb tias tsis, cov lus hais cia crammed lub plawv. Vim li cas cov lus "ua uas tsis yog nrog peb yog tawm tsam peb" nyob rau hauv Latin suab ntau npaum li cas impressive? Leej tsis yog nobiscum, adversus Peb yog ...

Tej zaum Lenin mob siab ib tug ntau ntawm lub sij hawm kawm hauj lwm ntawm lub philosopher thiab anarchist Max Stirner. Nws yog rho nrog cov authorship ntawm qhov no txhais ntawm lub biblical cov ntawv nyeem. Nws tseem mus nrhiav seb leej twg hais tias nws thawj zaug, tab sis txhua yam yog yooj yim heev: Stirner tuag nyob rau hauv 1856, thaum Lenin yug xwb nyob rau hauv 1870.

Ntuj muab faib rau kev qhia

Hlostkaya thiab capacious kab lus kom meej meej highlight ntsiab lus tseem ceeb thiab yuam cov menyuam kawm ntawv coj "txoj cai" sab. Tej zaum nws yog txaus kom tig cov lus "uas yog tsis nrog peb yog tawm tsam peb" nyob rau hauv ib tug tiag tiag Bolshevik lus hais tias. Slogans zoo coj hauv paus nyob rau hauv lub fertile av ntawm loj illiteracy ntawm lub proletariat, tab sis ntawm lub biblical keeb kwm ntawm cov kab zauv hais lus xum tsis mus. Tab sis, feem ntau yuav, lawv tsuas yog tsis paub phau Vajlugkub nyob rau hauv xws nthuav dav mus nqa tawm ib co parallels.

Yog yus siv lub apt qhia, backed los ntawm ib tug ntev li keeb kwm, los ntawm lub sij hawm rau lub sij hawm tsim thaum nyob rau hauv sib txawv hais lus, tab sis nws suab heev radically. Tsis muaj zem uas nyob rau hauv peb hnub cov kab lus yog ntshai ua ib txhoj puab heev thiab uncompromising.

Qhov kev tsimnyog ntawm cov kab lus nrog ib tug txawv kev xav overtones

Yuav ua li cas ib tug neeg uas nyob rau hauv lub tshav kub ntawm heartfelt hais lus cuam cov kab lus "uas yog tsis nrog peb yog tawm tsam peb"? Tam sim no qhov no qhia tau xwb hopelessly lwj lub tswv yim, thiab es tsis txhob ntawm cov phoojywg, uas xav kom tau txais ib tug politician nyob rau hauv no yav tas, nws yuav tau txais ib barrage ntawm kev thuam.

Kawm European haiv neeg nws ua raws li txoj cai ntawm kam rau ua, muab cov neeg uas muaj ib tug dav spectrum ntawm tib neeg txoj cai thiab kev ywj siab. Yog li ntawd yog dab tsi yog ib tug ntse zoo ntawm ib tug ntshiab unquestionable Zoo siab phem yog nyob zoo ib sarcastic teb. Cuaj kaum, peb yuav tsum lees paub hais tias cov radical nqe lus yog nws kiv cua, thiab ces cov nom tswv qhov teeb meem pib deteriorate.

Feem ntau nyob rau hauv ib tug sib tham nrog cov kab lus hais kom meej meej thuam suab - thaum ib tug neeg pib dhau ardently tiv thaiv lawv lub rooj, contrasting txawv cov pab pawg neeg thiab hnov txog tus nqi txiav txim. Tseeb, tsis yog tau txais tus pog heev, nws to taub li cas mus deb heev thiab yuav zoo ib yam li Lenin, broadcasting los ntawm ib tug armored tsheb rau hauv yuav tsum tau ntawm lub ntiaj teb no kiv puag ncig, raws li cov voltage dauv. Ntawm cov hoob kawm, qhov no tsuas yog siv rau cov uas tsim nyog tus neeg uas muaj peev xwm raug ntsuam xyuas lub mus ob peb vas ntawm cov neeg tuaj saib thiab kho cov kev taw qhia ntawm kev hais lus.

Tam sim no peb yog adorned nrog xws li radical slogans, tsis yog npaum li cas tiag, yog li speechwriters sim los ua ib tug kuas ntawv, uas yog tsis tau tso cai erroneous los yog tsis meej xwm txhais, thiab (yog tias ua tau) no tsis yog radical rhetoric thiab categorical tsis txaus siab.